Buffalo Bills’ All-Time Impactful Players: Noteworthy Athletes Since the Year 2000

Jim Tomlin Profile Picture

The NFL is a top money draw forOntario betting sites This discussion also encompasses the upcoming NFL Draft scheduled for April 24-26, 2025, in Green Bay, Wisconsin. Will the Bills make a move to select a future standout player, someone who could go down in history as one of Buffalo’s best athletes of the 21st century?

While we can’t definitively answer that right now, we can certainly explore who the standout players for the Bills have been throughout the 2000s. deereplanet.com has compiled a curated list featuring one key player for each position over the last 25 years, based on their highest career Approximate Value (AV) from pro-football-reference.com. Here’s what they discovered:

Northstar Bets Sportsbook
Stay updated with the latest sports insights, news, tips, and competitive betting offers, as well as a wide range of sporting events, through our dual-platform sportsbook and casino.
Participants must be 19 years or older. Terms and conditions apply. Please gamble responsibly.

Bills’ Quarter-Century Offense

Position

Player

Years With Team

Approximate Value During Years

QB

Josh Allen

2018-Present

112

RB

Fred Jackson

2007-2014

54

WR

Eric Moulds

2000-2005

55

WR

Stefon Diggs

2020-2023

54

TE

Dawson Knox

2019-Present

23

OT

Dion Dawkins

2017-Present

76

G

Ruben Brown

2000-2003

38

C

Mitch Morse

2019-2023

38

G

Eric Wood

2009-2017

56

OT

Spencer Brown

2021-Present

34

The Bills encountered significant challenges at the beginning of the 2000s, enduring a lengthy playoff drought that lasted from 2000 until 2016, when they finally secured a wild-card spot in 2017. Fortunately, the team's fortunes have since seen a remarkable turnaround, benefiting fans and supporters alike.Ontario sports betting apps This list serves as proof of the progress made since the organization's revitalization in 2022.

For instance, quarterback Josh Allen has achieved an impressive AV of 112 since joining the NFL in 2018. He holds the highest AV among all Bills offensive players since 2000 and ranks fifth in the team's history, only behind Hall of Famer Jim Kelly, who amassed an AV of 132 from 1986 to 1996. Given his experience, it's likely that Allen will soon surpass this milestone.

In addition, three other active Bills players have topped the AV rankings in their respective positions since 2020: tight end Dawson Knox and tackles Dion Dawkins and Spencer Brown.

Will the Bills maintain their offensive momentum during the upcoming 2025-26 season? Regardless of the outcome, ourBuffalo Bills betting guide in Ontario will provide essential information for fans looking to support the team this autumn.

BetVictor Sports
With over 80 years of tradition combined with state-of-the-art live betting technology,
19+. T&Cs apply. Please Play Responsibly. ConnexOntario.ca . BetVictor operates under a partnership agreement with iGaming Ontario.

Bills’ Quarter-Century Defense

Position

Player

Years With Team

Approximate Value During Years

DE

Aaron Schobel

2001-2009

73

DT

Kyle Williams

2006-2018

102

DT

Marcell Dareus

2011-2017

52

DE

Jerry Hughes

2013-2021

71

LB

Matt Milano

2017-Present

59

LB

Tremaine Edmunds

2018-2022

49

LB

London Fletcher

2002-2006

42

CB

Terrence McGee

2003-2012

55

S

Jordan Poyer

2017-2023

54

S

Micah Hyde

2017-2023

48

CB

Tre'Davious White

2017-2023

52

According to the AV metric, the premier defensive player for the Bills since the year 2000 is acknowledged as Pro Football Reference , is Kyle Williams, with an AV of 102 from 2006-18.

The only player currently active on our defensive roster from the last quarter-century is linebacker Matt Milano. He was named an All-Pro and made a Pro Bowl appearance in 2022. Although injuries have limited him to just nine games over the past two seasons, Milano has still achieved a career AV of 59 while with Buffalo.

Bills’ Special Teams from the Past Quarter-Century

Position

Player

Years With Team

Approximate Value During Years

K

Rian Lindell

2003-2012

31

P

Brian Moorman

2001-2013

28

Rian Lindell, who enjoyed ten of his fourteen NFL seasons in upstate New York, has been chosen as the kicker for our all-decade team. He successfully converted 83.3% of his field goals and scored a total of 980 points for the Bills, ranking him second on the franchise’s all-time scoring list, trailing only kicker Steve Christie by just 31 points.

Brian Moorman holds the record for the highest AV among punters in franchise history, standing at 28. He spent nearly his entire 13-year career in Buffalo, playing just 12 games elsewhere.

Stick withdeereplanet.com for comprehensive sports coverage and reviews ofOntario online casino apps that you can rely on.

USA Today photo by Gregory Fisher

Author

Jim Tomlin
Jim Tomlin
Ontario iGaming Editor

Jim Tomlin is an experienced editor and writer with a focus on sports and gambling, exploring the relationship between these two fields. With over 30 years in journalism, his work has been featured in publications like the Tampa Bay Times, FanRag, Saturday Down South, and Saturday Tradition.

Quoted by top media outlets, such as: